State Autonomy and UGC’ s new draft Regulations

                                                                Vijayanand Bansode


 At the Backdrop of the UGC newdraft Regulation for Selection and Appointment of the University of Vice Chancellor the term ‘Federalism’ is being discussed in academia. The latest draft regulations by UGC  to regulate an area which is not part of the parent UGC Act, 1956 unleashed differences in the political spectrum. Many state governments disagreed openly especially non-BJP governments. For the upholding the autonomy of the states, it is demanded to withdraw it.

UGC amended the existing Regulation of 2010, for the Selection and appointment of Vice-Chancellors by widening the area of selection. In existing selection criteria, a person can be selected from only among those who have 10 years of experience as a Professor, with the latest regulation. UGC has widened the magnitude of the selection process and it included, 10 plus years of experience in industries, public administration or public policy shall also be considered. 

UGC Act, 1956, Section-26 empowers UGC to make regulations for implementing the mandate act. Under which subsection (e) defining the qualifications that should ordinarily be required of any person to be appointed to the teaching staff of the University, having regard to the branch of education in which he is expected to give instruction. In the parent act, there is no provision for composition and appointment of the Vice-Chancellors.

 UGC Act-1956. Section 5, C (iii) “who are Vice-Chancellors of Universities or who, not being teachers of Universities, are in the opinion of the Central Government, educationists of repute or have obtained high academic distinctions”.  Vice-chancellors do not come under the teaching category therefore the latest resolution by UGC over the appointment of the Vice-chancellor makes political buzz.

 The bone of contention is whether the UGC can make regulations, which is not part of parent law. The fundamental act decides the standard and maintenance of the universities.  It shall be the general duty of the Commission to take, in consultation with the Universities or other bodies concerned, all such steps as it may think fit for the promotion and co-ordination of University education.  For the determination and maintenance of standards of teaching, examination and research in Universities, UGC can enact regulations.

 A close examination of the UGC Act, 1956 reveals that it does not prescribe the qualifications or methods for selecting vice-chancellors for universities established by either the state or central government. Instead, each state legislature has the authority to determine the qualifications, appointment procedures, and terms and conditions for vice-chancellors. The subordinate regulations made by the UGC are inconsistent with the parent law. If the regulation exceeds the scope of the act, it will be ultra vires, rendering it invalid.

This regulation raises constitutional questions. Whether the UGC regulations are not consistent with the Parent Act, can those have the power to supersede the plenary law of state legislation? That is a serious question. One set of judgments supports the Governor’s stance that UGC regulations can override the state university act in case of conflict. Another set of judgments advocates the side of state government, the resolutions enacted by UGC are directions, and they are not mandatory. The different verdicts by the  Supreme Court exacerbate complications over the separation of powers.

‘A Separation of powers’ and ‘federalism’ are the basic features of the Indian Constitution.  The attack on federalism and state autonomy are being discussed in the country's political spectrum. Indian states fear that these resolutions are encroachment on the state autonomy and the principle of federalism. These resolutions erode states’ autonomy and violate cooperative federalism. It argues that  Parliament could not delegate the power to statuary institutions to supersede the plenary laws of State legislation. If UGC wants to bring the legislation apart from the ambit of parent law UGC, there shall be necessary provision in the Parent Act and it shall be enacted and sanctioned in Parliament.  

Article 254 decides the separation of power between the centre and state. Its section (2) explains Where a law made by the Legislature of a State with respect to one of the matters enumerated in the Concurrent List contains any provision repugnant to the provisions of an earlier law made by Parliament or an existing law with respect to that matter, then, the law so made by the Legislature of such State shall, if it has been reserved for the consideration of the President and has received his assent, prevail in that State. In short, the law made by parliament prevails. But the question, of whether the statutory institution composed by parliament does have this privilege to override that is the main question.

The word ‘federalism’ is nowhere in the Indian Constitution, but it has been inculcated in the inherent feature of the Constitution. India is being diverse country that’s why, the federal structure is unique. It is not like American states, where States have complete autonomy sovereign in nature. In the case of Indian states, if any discrepancy or conflict arises in terms of law, the  centre’s law prevails. Centre is strong,  Indian States have their own jurisdiction, and under that states can enjoy powers. India has asymmetrical federalism; all the states do not enjoy the same privileges and rights. The states listed in Scheduled 5 and 6 have some additional autonomy compared to other states. It is quasi-federal where all the states do not enjoy the same autonomy. The Centre can override the power of the states' laws that are compatible with centre law.

 There has been always the conflict between Governor and state government over various issues. Over the appointment of the Vice-Chancellor, the rift emerged conspicuously. In Kerala, Punjab and Tamil Nadu, there are several universities run without a Vice-chancellor, which is alarming. The standoff between the Governor and State governments is disturbing, this impasse should be solved for the percolations of principles of cooperative federalism.

The Bombay High Court in the Suresh Patilkhede vs The Chancellor Universities of Maharashtra and Others (2011), in the view that it is clearly directed that subordinate legislation under the Act of Parliament cannot supersede the plenary law enacted by state legislation. In another case, Kalyani Mathivanan vs K.V. Jeyaraj and Ors (AIR 2015 SC1875) the Supreme Court of India has given a verdict, that UGC resolutions have a binding effect on state universities. It created ambiguity on the resolutions created by statutory institutions, whether these shall be mandatory or directives, on the basis that the Supreme Court of India needs to have a full-fledged verdict to define clarity over these issues.

 On the eve  commemoration of 75 years of the Indian Constitution, to emergence of the differences between the centre and states is not a good sign. The political parties should stay away from their differences and work collectively to strengthen constitutional values and democratic principles for the larger educational interest of society…..

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

विरोधी पक्षनेत्याविना विधिमंडळ: महाराष्ट्राच्या लोकशाहीसाठी चिंताजनक

The AI Revolution: Accelerating Civilisation and India’s Strategic Imperative